Rental Cars & Insurance: What Your Policy Actually Covers

Let’s face it, insurance isn’t usually what gets the party started. But here at Blue Sky Insurance, we believe even topics like rental car coverage can be more thrilling than a minivan with a turbo engine. So buckle up! We're diving into the world of rental car coverage... without putting you to sleep in the driver's seat.

First, Let’s Clear Up the Confusion

You’ve probably heard the term “rental car coverage” tossed around like spaghetti at a family dinner. But here’s the deal:

There are two different things people mean when they say rental car coverage:

1. 🚘 Coverage for a rental car you use while your car is in the shop
2. 🧳 Coverage for a rental car you're renting while traveling or on vacation

They sound the same, but they’re not. So, let’s break them down.

1. 🚘 Rental Reimbursement Coverage (When Your Car Is in the Shop)
This is an optional add-on to your personal auto policy. It pays for a rental car while your own vehicle is being repaired after a covered claim, like a fender bender or a tree that mistook your hood for a nap spot.
Quick Facts:

• It doesn't cover vacation rentals.
• It kicks in only after a covered loss.
• There’s usually a daily limit (like $30–$50/day).
• Coverage lasts only while your car is being repaired, not while you're just waiting for your mechanic to text you back.

This is basically your "backup ride" when life gives you lemons (and those lemons hit your bumper).

2. 🧳 Coverage for a Rental Car While Traveling (A.k.a. “Do I Need That Extra Insurance at the Counter?”)

You're at the rental car counter. You're excited. You’re heading to sunny beaches or mountain views. Suddenly, the agent asks, “Would you like to add our insurance for just $19.99/day?” Cue the panic. 😱 Here’s where your personal auto policy might save the day.

If You Have a Personal Auto Policy:
In most cases, if you rent a car for personal use in the U.S. or Canada, your existing policy will extend to that rental, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, depending on what you carry.

BUT... It Depends On:

• What’s on your current policy
• The limits and deductibles you have
• Whether you're renting for business or personal use
• If you’re renting internationally (spoiler alert: your policy probably won’t follow you to Europe)

​
So if you only have liability on your personal car, that’s all you’re bringing to the rental car party. 🚫 No collision or comprehensive means damage to the rental car may not be covered, which could leave your wallet feeling very attacked. We usually suggest paying the rental car company for comprehensive & collision to avoid the headache of having your policy pay out for any damage you may cause to the rental car. But purchasing the liability, as long as you have it today, is not required.